Authors
1 Medical Ethics Department, Medical School, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran
2 Medical Ethics Department, School of Traditional Medicine, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
3 English Language Department, Paramedical School, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran
Abstract
Introduction: The newly deceased patients have long been usedin medical schools to teach clinical skills without any challengesas it helps to train skilled doctors. Nowadays, the use of moulagesand simulators are common in teaching clinical skills since thesetools provide the opportunity for frequent practice without anypain and injury. There are specific procedures which still requirethe use of cadavers. However, the increased significance ofpatient rights has generally challenged the practicality of usingthe deceased bodies for this purpose. This study was designedwith the aim of determining to what extent clinical skill trainingis dependent on the recently deceased patients.Methods: This was a cross-sectional mixed-method triangulationdesign conducted in two phases. In the first phase, a researcher-madequestionnaire was used to collect quantitative data of the medicalstudents and residents. The data were used to assess the frequencyof experience. In the second stage, semi-structured interviews wereconducted with faculty members and fellows in order to evaluatethe educational impact of this type of procedure and the influentialfactors. The quantitative data were analyzed using statisticalsoftware, and the qualitative codes were extracted following acontent analysis. Finally, a comparative analysis was performed.Results: Twenty five residents (26%) and seven medical students(14%) had the experience of performing procedures on therecently deceased patients for training purposes. About half ofthe residents and 33% of the medical students had observed theircolleagues practicing procedures on cadavers. In the qualitativephase, the main categories included professional ethics, law andeducational requirements.Conclusion: A relatively low number of medical students andresidents had experienced procedures on the newly deceasedpatients. In this regard, ethical, religious and legal concerns mighthave played a part despite the desire to learn. It would be effectiveto direct these educational experiences toward proceduresthat cannot be mastered through moulages and simulators, andto lay the legal and executive ground so that performing theseprocedures under the supervision of professors, and with a levelof documentation would have no legal challenges.Keywords: Cadaver, Learning, Clinical skills, Ethics
- Smith T. The Westminster review. London: Baldwin,
- Cradock and Joy; 1824.
- Burns JP, Reardon FE, Truog RD. Using Newly
- Deceased Patients to Teach Resuscitation Procedures.
- NEngl J Med. 1994;331(24):1652-5.
- Brattebo G, Seim SH. Teaching and training of invasive
- procedures on cadavers. Lancet. 1988; 2(8619):1078-9.
- Orlowski JP, Kanoti GA, Mehlman MJ. The ethics
- of using newly dead patients for teaching and
- practicing intubation techniques. N Engl J Med.
- ;319(7):439-41.
- Orlowski JP, Kanoti GA, Mehlman MJ. The ethical
- dilemma of permitting the teaching and perfecting of
- resuscitation techniques on recently expired patients.
- J Clin Ethics. 1990;1(3):201-5.
- Schwid HA, Rooke GA, Carline J, Steadman
- RH, Murray WB, Olympio M, et al. Evaluation
- of anesthesia residents using mannequin-based
- simulation: a multiinstitutional study. Anesthesiology.
- ;97(6):1434-44.
- Bond WF, Spillane L. The use of simulation for
- emergency medicine resident assessment. Acad Emerg
- Med. 2002;9(11):1295-9.
- Hutton IA, Kenealy H, Wong C. Using simulation
- models to teach junior doctors how to insert chest
- tubes: a brief and effective teaching module. Intern
- Med J. 2008;38(12):887-91.
- Makowski AL. The Ethics of Using the Recently
- Deceased to Instruct Residents in Cricothyrotomy.
- Ann Emerg Med. 2015;66(4):403-8.
- Morag RM, DeSouza S, Steen PA, Salem A, Harris M,
- Ohnstad O, et al. Performing procedures on the newly
- deceased for teaching purposes: what if we were to
- ask? Arch Intern Med. 2005;165(1):92-6.
- Schmidt TA, Abbott JT, Geiderman JM, Hughes JA,
- Johnson CX, McClure KB, et al. Ethics seminars: the
- ethical debate on practicing procedures on the newly
- dead. Acad Emerg Med. 2004;11(9):962-6.
- Mirzazadeh A, Ostadrahimi N, Ghalandarpoorattar
- SM, Asghari F. Teaching endotracheal intubation on
- the recently deceased: opinion of patients and families.
- J Med Ethics Hist Med. 2014;7:5.
- Hashemi A, Yeketaz H, Asghari F. Developing an
- ethical guideline for clinical teaching in Tehran
- University of Medical Sciences. J Med Ethics Hist
- Med. 2015; 8:5.
- Tavakol M, Sandars J. Quantitative and qualitative
- methods in medical education research: AMEE Guide
- No 90: Part II. Med Teach. 2014;36(10):838-48.
- Schifferdecker KE, Reed VA. Using mixed methods
- research in medical education: basic guidelines for
- researchers. Med Educ. 2009;43(7):637-44.
- Ginifer C, Kelly AM. Teaching resuscitation skills
- using the newly deceased. Med J Aust. 1996;165(8):
- -7.
- Denny CJ, Kollek D. Practicing procedures on the
- recently dead. J Emerg Med. 1999;17(6):949-52.
- Fourre MW. The performance of procedures on the
- recently deceased. Acad Emerg Med. 2002;9(6):595-8.
- Tonks A. Intubation Practice on Cadavers Should Stop.
- BMJ. 1992;305(6849):332.
- Wicclair MR. Ethics and research with deceased
- patients. Cambridge quarterly of healthcare ethics.
- ;17(1):87-97.
- Gomes AP, Rego S, Palacios M, Siqueira-Batista R.
- Bioethical analysis of the use of the newly deceased in
- medical training. Rev Assoc Med Bras. 2010;56(1):11-6.
- Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs of the American
- Medical Association. Performing procedures on the
- newly deceased. Acad Med. 2002;77(12):1212-6.
- Moore GP. Ethics seminars: the practice of medical
- procedures on newly dead patients is consent
- warranted? Acad Emerg Med. 2001;8(4):389-92.
- Tabas JA, Rosenson J, Price DD, Rohde D, Baird CH,
- Dhillon N. A comprehensive, unembalmed cadaverbased
- course in advanced emergency procedures for
- medical students. Acad Emerg Med. 2005;12(8):782-5.
- Iserson KV. Postmortem procedures in the emergency
- department: using the recently dead to practise and
- teach. J Med Ethics. 1993;19(2):92-8.
- Berger JT, Rosner F, Cassell EJ. Ethics of Practicing
- Medical Procedures on Newly Dead and Nearly Dead
- Patients. J Gen Intern Med. 2002;17(10):774-8.
- Kojuri J, Amini M, Karimian Z, Dehghani MR, Saber
- M, Bazrafcan L. Needs assessment and evaluation of
- a short course to improve faculties teaching skills at
- a former World Health Organization regional teacher
- training center. J Adv Med Educ Prof. 2015;3(1):1-8.
)